Best Substitutes For Rosemary -  Make Your Meals Tasty And Professional

Best Substitutes for Rosemary - Make Your Meals Tasty And Professional

Last updated: 16 December, 2021

Models Considered 10 Models Considered
Hours of Research 150 Hours of Research
Experts Interviewed 85 Experts Interviewed
Reviews Analyzed 180 Reviews Analyzed
If you are looking for a good substitute to fresh rosemary, then congratulations! You have found it.

We here at BSRMP believe that there is no one true substitute for the flavor of fresh rosemary but we do have some suggestions on how to make your meal taste great without having to go out and buy this elusive herb.

There are many different herbs that can be substituted for fresh rosemary, but not all will work well in all dishes. Here are our top 5 picks for substitutes along with their strengths and weaknesses.

Comparision Table:

Best Overall
Monterey Bay Spice Rosemary Whole

Poultry, lamb, pork, and roast vegetable dishes

Read Our Review
10
TechscoreTM
?
Premium Quality
NOMU Essentials Dried Sage Leaves

Casseroles, stews, poultry, pastas, and salads

Read Our Review
9.9
TechscoreTM
?
Best For Optimal Freshness
Denver Spice Summer Savory-4oz-Adds Subtle Herb Flavor

Poultry, pork, lamb, and root vegetables

Read Our Review
9.8
TechscoreTM
?
Best Visual Interest
McCormick Culinary Thyme Leaves

Poultry, pork, lamb, soup, and vegetables

Read Our Review
9.7
TechscoreTM
?
Low Calories And Carbs
Naturevibe Botanicals Tarragon Leaves

Sauces, salad dressings, stock, fish, and meat

Read Our Review
9.6
TechscoreTM
?
Best Organic Farming
Simply Organic Basil Certified Organic, 0.54-Ounce Container
9.5
TechscoreTM
?
Pleasant Aroma
McCormick Marjoram Leaves

Pasta sauces, mushrooms, salads, and marinade

Read Our Review
9.4
TechscoreTM
?
Use In Season Soups
Happy Belly Bay Leaves

Meat, fish, and sauces

Read Our Review
9.3
TechscoreTM
?
Best Culinary Experience
Delish Gourmet Caraway Seeds

Vegetables, meat, marinades, curries, and bread

Read Our Review
9.2
TechscoreTM
?
Perfect For Italian Cooking
Tone's Italian Seasoning

Meats, sauces, marinades, roast vegetables, and stews

Read Our Review
9.1
TechscoreTM
?

1. Monterey Bay Spice Rosemary Whole - Best Overall

Features
  • Dimension: 11.46 x 8.35 x 2.01 inches
  • Weight: 1 Pounds
Check Price

Monterey Bay Spice Company’s organic whole rosemary is a versatile herb that can be used in many applications. Rosemary is often paired with potatoes, and it works well in salad dressings, baked goods, sauces and marinades. It also pairs well with basil, garlic and onions.


Monterey Bay Spice Company’s California-grown rosemary is dried to perfection for convenience so you can enjoy the natural freshness of this herb year-round.

2. NOMU Essentials Dried Sage Leaves - Premium Quality

Features
  • Dimension: ‎ 6.75 x 1.89 x 1.89 inches
  • Weight: 0.98 Ounces
Check Price

Sage is a perennial herb that has been used for centuries to season food. It adds a light flavor to dishes, especially poultry and pork. Sage also helps with digestion of fatty meats.

NOMU Essentials Dried Sage Leaves are made by rubbing whole leaves, which allows the sage to integrate into the ingredients without adding any extra pieces or spice.

3. Denver Spice Summer Savory-4oz-Adds Subtle Herb Flavor - Best For Optimal Freshness

Features
  • Dimension: 6.3 x 4.6 x 1.5 inches
  • Weight: 0.64 Ounces
Check Price

Denver Spice Summer Savory 4oz - Adds Subtle Herb Flavor
Packed in a heat-sealed re-sealable poly pouch
Shipping in 24 Hours or Less on All Orders
Multi-Item Shipping Discounts Available at Our Amazon Store
Each Order includes a coupon code for future orders.

This product is sold by Denver Spice and Fulfilled by Amazon. Gift wrapping available. Packed to Order for Optimal Freshness Ingredients: Summer Savory, Water, Salt, Garlic Powder, Onion Powder, Spices and Natural Flavorings Net Weight: 4 Kg

4. McCormick Culinary Thyme Leaves - Best Visual Interest

Features
  • Dimension: 8.1 x 3.7 x 2.8 inches
  • Weight: 6 Ounces
Check Price

McCormick Culinary Thyme Leaves are sourced especially for chefs, and carefully selected to ensure optimal quality and performance with exceptional flavor and added visual interest. McCormick Culinary Thyme Leaves showcase a gentle flavor that’s a bit earthy and warm with lemony, minty tones.

McCormick Culinary Thyme Leaves bring distinctive taste to soups, meat and seafood entrées and mashed potatoes. Our 6 oz size fits in perfectly with any operation’s spices and seasonings collection.

5. Naturevibe Botanicals Tarragon Leaves - Low Calories And Carbs

Features
  • Dimension: 8.07 x 4.96 x 0.94 inches
  • Weight: 1.45 Ounces
Check Price

It is a perennial herb of the family Apiaceae, native to Asia Minor. It has aromatic leaves and small yellow flowers. It is sometimes called estragon or “dragon herb” because it was said to be guarded by dragons, but today more commonly known as tarragon.

The French word estragon is derived from the Greek word staragnos (meaning "little dragon").
Tarragon has a sweet anise-like flavor that goes well with potatoes, carrots, chicken, fish and eggs. 

6. Simply Organic Basil Certified Organic, 0.54-Ounce Container - Best Organic Farming

Features
  • Dimension: 2.1 x 1.9 x 4.3 inches
  • Weight: 0.54 Ounces
Check Price

Simply Organic Basil is a Certified Organic, Egyptian, extra-fancy grade basil to enliven every tomato-based recipe. 0.54 ounces; Glass bottle.

Certified organic, kosher and fair trade ingredients are used in this Simply Organic product line. 1% of sales supports organic farming and the environment through The Simply Organic Commitment. A Brand of Frontier Co-op, responsible to people and planet since 1972.

7. McCormick Marjoram Leaves - Pleasant Aroma

Features
  • Dimension: 1.77 x 2.19 x 1.77 inches
  • Weight: 0.2 Ounces
Check Price

McCormick Marjoram Leaves are a premium quality dried herb that embodies a pleasant aroma and warm taste. It is great for flavoring vegetables, sauces, dressings and more!

McCormick Marjoram Leaves are a premium quality dried herb that embodies a pleasant aroma and warm taste. It is great for flavoring vegetables, sauces, dressings and more! These leaves mix well with bread cubes for stuffings or can be added to recipes calling for fresh marjoram. 

8. Happy Belly Bay Leaves - Use In Season Soups

Features
  • Dimension: 1.88 x 1.88 x 4.94 inches
  • Weight: 0.25 Ounces
Check Price

The aromatic leaf from the bay laurel tree adds a distinctive flavor to all your favorite recipes. Use whole leaves to season soups, stews, and braises, risotto, pasta sauce, or even a simple pot of rice.

Or use ground bay leaves for baking and seasoning meatloaf or other savory dishes. Happy Belly Bay Leaves are Kosher certified. 

9. Delish Gourmet Caraway Seeds - Best Culinary Experience

Features
  • Dimension: 6.06 x 2.56 x 2.48 inches
  • Weight: 9.14 Ounces
Check Price

Delish Gourmet Caraway Seeds are premium quality gourmet whole caraway seeds. The Delish brand is a family business for over 25 years. Our products are non-GMO and all natural.

We offer variety packs to choose from 1 lb 2 lbs 5 lbs 10 lbs 15lbs 20lb Bulk bags & Jars. Caraway seed is an herb that comes from the carrot plant, it has a distinctive aroma and flavor similar to black pepper or cumin.

10. Tone's Italian Seasoning - Perfect For Italian Cooking

Features
  • Dimension: 7.75 x 3.5 x 2.6 inches
  • Weight: 8.8 Ounces
Check Price

Tone’s Italian Seasoning is a blend of classic whole Italian herbs such as oregano, thyme, basil, rosemary and sage. This harmonious blend unifies all the different flavors of the herbs. Produces a flavor that is camphorous and minty and perfect for Mediterranean and Italian cooking.

Mix with tomato sauce for pizza, marinara sauce, minestrone, calzone and all Italian dishes. This product will deliver the most flavor if gently crushed before adding to foods.

Buying Guide

Thyme is often known as the closest substitute to rosemary, but there are some differences that you should be aware of. Flavor wise, thyme has a much milder taste with earthy and citrusy notes.

In addition, thyme contains a higher percentage of vitamins and minerals than rosemary does. If you're looking for other substitutes for this herb, here are 10 options from our reviews and buying guides!

Thyme is often known as the closest substitute to rosemary, but they are not exactly the same. This article will compare and contrast thyme with rosemary to help you decide which one might work best in your dish.

Thyme has a much milder flavor than rosemary, so it's good if you don't want something too strong of a taste. It also contains more nutrients than rosemary does - including vitamins and minerals. On the other hand, if you're looking for something that tastes similar to what you get at most restaurants or grocery stores.

FAQ

What Flavor Is Rosemary?

Rosemary has a very notable sage-like flavor, with a lemony aroma and woody, minty, and pine notes.

Can I Substitute Lavender for Rosemary?

Lavender is a decent substitute for rosemary, especially in fruity dishes, drinks, and Mexican cuisine. However, lavender doesn’t have that minty, pine-flavored punch that rosemary is known for.

Is Rosemary A Good Substitute for Thyme?

Rosemary works pretty well as a replacement for thyme, but since thyme is much milder, you need to halve the amount specified in the recipe.

Final Verdict:

The best substitutes for rosemary are not necessarily the same as other herbs. This article will tell you about all of the different types of herbs that can be used to replace rosemary in cooking, along with reviews and buying guides!

Thyme is an herb that tastes very similar to rosemary but tends to have a more spicy flavor. It’s perfect in marinades or when using it fresh on top of grilled meats or vegetables. To substitute thyme for rosemary, use 1 teaspoon thyme leaves per tablespoon dried or 2 teaspoons fresh thyme leaves per tablespoon dried.

THE TEAM THAT WORKED ON THIS REVIEW

ADRIANA

ADRIANA

(Writer)

AMANDA

AMANDA

(EXPERT CONSULTANT)

DIANA

DIANA

(SENIOR EDITOR)

ELYSE

ELYSE

(Writer)

JENNIFER

JENNIFER

(PHOTOGRAPHER)

Leave a Comment